If you cock and brandish a brush, you better be prepared to fire it at the canvas / false biographies
Edgar Degas was not born in a parsonage in a small farming community where the builder’s tea flowed like wine and the hedge rows carved up the meadows into labyrinths only a rural Daedalus could navigate. He was born I know not where, perhaps in Utrecht or Corfu, but honestly probably not.
He didn’t burn the boats but he could have heard about the man who did. He could delineate the supple grace of limbs and the acute longing for the music or the race to finally start.
John Baldessari did not grow up in Delaware County Pennsylvania with its meth labs and quarries and a populace of townsfolk habituated to think of twenty years ago as halcyon glow of mediocrity compared to the present’s abject inequity. He didn’t grow up on a sugar beet farm in North Dakota either, his only friend a sway-backed horse named Pegasus.
He didn’t suffer savants any more easily than he suffered fools, and he could paint but he stopped and in the stopping he found a pattern language the grammar of which is still unspooling.
Agnes Martin didn’t grow up attending a one room schoolhouse a few miles from the banks of the Niobrara with a pack of Airedales sunning lazily in the patch of grass between the house and the barn where the cattle chewed cud and contemplated becoming hamburger. She didn’t situate herself against the conventions and mores of lace-curtain Irish from Newton as a townie whose brothers worked in the mills because she didn’t live in Lowell or anywhere else in Massachusetts either, so far as I know.
She could give articulate a mute symphony of feeling without a figure or a background, and do her own art as rigorously as Warhol could publicize and as assiduously as Kippenberger could self destruct.
It is rather late to observe how much significance we have invested on the idea of chopping down a cherry tree. Too much significance. I can’t pretend otherwise. Have you heard the Pando is dying? Is that fact not equally salient, in the larger scheme of things? If the scheme of things is considered in a large enough frame, significance is emptied of meaning, yes? And then is art just a consolatory gasp?
